Considering where the market stands for starting pitchers, the Indians C.C. Sabathia could command up to $20 million a year on his next deal, according to the Akron Beacon Journal. Sabathia, last year's AL Cy Young winner, will become a free agent in October. RealGM Note: Sabathia, who was the second best pitcher in the MLB last season and eighth best player overall according to our FIC metric, 'deserved' to make $15.7 million. He actually made $8.75 million, which gave him a Reina Value of +79%.