San Diego's Andrew Cashner won and Cleveland's Vinnie Pestano lost as pitchers split decisions Saturday in baseball's first salary arbitration cases in two years, according to an ESPN.com report.

Cashner will make $2.4M rather than the club's offer of $2.275M, the smallest gap this year among cases that didn't settle. Pestano will make $975,000 instead of his request for $1.45M.