Alex Rodriguez hit his major league leading 14th home run, a three-run shot, but the Yankees failed to hold leads of 4-0 and 6-2, as their 10 game win streak came to an end.
Miguel Olivo singled in Jeremy Reed in the 8th, the go-ahead run against Tom Gordon.
Ron Villone gave up two hits in the ninth, but got picked up the save, his first of the season.
Olivo's RBI Single In The 8th Breaks Yankees 10-Game Streak