Team Archives
7th Jan, 2009
Grading The Deal: Giambi Returns To Oakland

24th Nov, 2008
Auditing The Oakland A's 2008 Season

Full Archive

MLB Columns
Search
RealGM Poll
Which team will sign Matt Holliday?

Yankees
Red Sox
Angels
Mets
Cardinals
Other



Poll Archives
Grading The Deal: Oakland Signs Cabrera
Christopher Reina. 3rd March, 2009 - 10:42 am


Current Features
L.A. DODGERS:
What The Dodgers Need This Winter

L.A. ANGELS:
Grading The Deal: Angels Re-Sign Bobby Abreu

MILWAUKEE:
Grading The Deal: Twins Deal For J.J. Hardy

N.Y. YANKEES:
Yankees' ALCS Hopes Hang On Free Agents

ST LOUIS:
Why The Cardinals Will Beat The Dodgers

PHILADELPHIA:
Phillies Begin Title Defense

WASHINGTON:
Finally Good Business Sense

ATLANTA:
Big Series Looming With Phillies

BOSTON:
Is Smoltz Done Or Just Warming Up?

TAMPA BAY:
Rays Haven't Reclaimed Last Year's Magic

SEATTLE:
Griffey's Wonderful Season Goes Beyond The Numbers

CHICAGO CUBS:
Making Moves Before The All-Star Game

CHICAGO WHITE SOX:
'Striking Out' With The White Sox, Late May

TORONTO:
Are The Jays For Real?

SAN FRANCISCO:
Behind Lincecum's Struggles On Opening Day

N.Y. METS:
Grading The Deal: Mets Cheaply Sign Sheffield

FLORIDA:
2009 Marlins Spring Summit

HOUSTON:
2009 Season Preview: Houston Astros

BALTIMORE:
2009 Season Preview: Baltimore Orioles

TEXAS:
2009 Season Preview: Texas Rangers

CLEVELAND:
Let 24 Bat Third?

ARIZONA:
‘Striking Out’ With The D-Backs: Late-February

SAN DIEGO:
‘Striking Out’ With The Padres: Mid-February

COLORADO:
'Striking Out' With The Rockies, Mid-February

KANSAS CITY:
Grading The Deal: Royals Make Huge Investment In Greinke

DETROIT:
Auditing The Detroit Tigers 2008 Season

CINCINNATI:
Auditing The Cincinnati Reds 2008 Season

MINNESOTA:
Auditing The Minnesota Twins 2008 Season

PITTSBURGH:
The Future Of The Pirates: A Sinking Ship Or Buried Treasure?


RealGM Search
Search:

The Oakland A's continued their aggressive offseason with an in-Spring Training move by signing shortstop Orlando Cabrera to a one-year, $4 million deal.

Cabrera had one excellent offensive season back in 2003 and has ben a fairly average player in most other seasons and is coming off arguably the least productive offensive year of his career. After going to the White Sox in exchange for Jon Garland, Cabrera hit .281/.334/.371 and was 14th amongst shortstops in OPS.

Not lost on people in Oakland is that Cabrera's .705 OPS easily beats Bobby Crosby's .645 and Edgar Renteria's .699. The former is the shortstop Cabrera will replace and the latter is who the Giants signed for $18.5 million over two years back in early December when the free agent market looked more slow than absolutely on life support.

Cabrera is 34 and gives the A's a band-aid upgrade at shortstop over Crosby, though I'm not sure if he is exactly worth the pick it will cost them, plus the $4 million. For a team under more normal budget constraints, Cabrera is an absolute bargain but Billy Beane always has to come to the table with fewer chips.

The 40 to even possibly 80 point difference in OPS between Cabrera and Crosby, however, will give the offense another .15 runs per game over the season. He will provide many more run producing opportunities for Matt Holliday than the alternatives and so this $4 million is also an investment in his $13.5 million.

Crosby is of course the player most affected by this signing, but given Eric Chavez's injury proclivity, he would be wise to join Michael Young on that third baseman crash course of 2009.

Additionally, Cabrera is still one of the better defensive shortstops, even though his range has declined.

Grade for Oakland: B+
© 2000-2009 RealGM, L.L.C. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Opportunities | About Us | Site Map | Contact RealGM