Team Archives
20th Oct, 2008
Appraising Manny's Proper Value

11th Mar, 2008
2008 Season Preview: Los Angeles Dodgers

Full Archive

MLB Columns
Search
RealGM Poll
Where will Manny Ramirez sign?

Dodgers
Giants
Yankees
Mets
Nationals
Other



Poll Archives
The Professor, Lugo Shipped to Dodgers
Joe Gutierrez. 31st July, 2006 - 9:01 pm


Current Features
TAMPA BAY:
Grading The Deal: Afforda-Burrell Big Signing By Rays

CHICAGO CUBS:
Grading The Deal: Bradley Signs For $30M

N.Y. YANKEES:
Grading The Deal: Teixeira Adds To Yanks' Offseason Of Shock And Awe

DETROIT:
Auditing The Detroit Tigers 2008 Season

CLEVELAND:
Will These Pitchers Bounce Back In 2009?

PHILADELPHIA:
Grading The Deal: Ibanez To Fill Burrell's Shoes In Left

FLORIDA:
Auditing The Florida Marlins 2008 Season

N.Y. METS:
Grading The Deal: Mets Close Deal On K-Rod

CINCINNATI:
Auditing The Cincinnati Reds 2008 Season

MILWAUKEE:
Auditing The Milwaukee Brewers 2008 Season

OAKLAND:
Auditing The Oakland A's 2008 Season

BOSTON:
Auditing The Boston Red Sox 2008 Season

MINNESOTA:
Auditing The Minnesota Twins 2008 Season

SAN DIEGO:
Appraising Jake Peavy's Trade Value

ST LOUIS:
Auditing The St. Louis Cardinals 2008 Season

TORONTO:
Auditing The Toronto Blue Jays 2008 Season

SAN FRANCISCO:
Auditing The San Francisco Giants 2008 Season

SEATTLE:
Mariners And A's Continue To Be Looking In At The Angels

HOUSTON:
Impeccable Timing Or Simple Overachieving?

ARIZONA:
Baby Backs Struggling Down The Stretch

WASHINGTON:
Last In Wins, First In Disappointment

BALTIMORE:
Orioles Soar Past Yankes, 12-2

COLORADO:
2008 Season Preview: Colorado Rockies

CHICAGO WHITE SOX:
2008 Season Preview: Chicago White Sox

L.A. ANGELS:
2008 Season Preview: Los Angeles Angels

ATLANTA:
2008 Season Preview: Atlanta Braves

PITTSBURGH:
The Future Of The Pirates: A Sinking Ship Or Buried Treasure?

KANSAS CITY:
Royal Dilemma: Alex Gordon Struggles Out Of The Gate

TEXAS:
Rangers To Finally Develop Via Pitching?


RealGM Search
Search:

You had to have known that GM Ned Colletti wasn’t going to turn his phone off during the final hours of the trading deadline. Rather than lose prospects to the Washington Nationals for slugger Alfonso Soriano, Colletti acquired that starting pitcher the Dodgers needed in the Cubs’ Greg Maddux. A rotation already consisting of All Star Brad Penny, Derek Lowe, and youngster Chad Billingsley, Maddux figures to be the 3rd or 4th starter.

In exchange for Maddux, the Cubs were able to land infielder Cesar Izturis. The former gold glover was basically a trade waiting to happen, especially with the acquisition of Wilson Betemit to take over at third base. Izturis couldn’t find a spot on the roster when Rafael Furcal arrived, who took over Izzy’s spot at short. He tried third but was moved to second base recently for the injured Jeff Kent.

The second deal announced after the acquisition of Maddux was that of SS Julio Lugo from the Tampa Bay Devil Rays for prospects Joel Guzman and Sergio Pedroza, who seems to be an always frequent trade partner with Los Angeles and Colletti. The trade for Lugo baffles me as to why Colletti swung a deal for yet another shortstop. From where it stands, Lugo figures to play 2B until the return of Kent, which has been reported to be in about a week or so. Betemit should be left at third for the remainder of the year, and Furcal is nested comfortably at shortstop. Where this leaves Lugo remains a question to Grady Little, who now has to platoon more players within the infield.

Overall, the trade for Julio Lugo was a move Colletti didn’t need to make. He knew the Dodgers needed offense, but Lugo is not the answer. Desperation for a hitter to impact the Dodgers lineup was not found by the GM, so he settled for Lugo. Changing positions probably isn’t the one thing the former D-Ray wants when he was dealt to Los Angeles. It looks like he will have to take over at third base once Kent returns. But, that leaves Betemit on the bench, something he thought he wouldn’t have to go back to when he was traded from the Braves.

Maddux adds his knowledge of the game to the pitching staff, but how long more does the “Mad Dog” have left in him? Julio Lugo wants roughly $10 million a year, and I certainly wouldn’t give another SS that caliber of money again. Being a free agent at the end of the season doesn’t make matters much better for the Dodgers. The smartest move Colletti didn’t trigger out of the deadline was not giving up the more important prospects the Dodgers possess. Added together, the Dodgers gave up Izturis, Guzman, and Pedroza for Maddux and Lugo.

They still need offense to help Nomar Garciaparra, but if Kent and the streaking J.D. Drew can wake up, a run at the NL West title is foreseeable.
© 2000-2008 RealGM, L.L.C. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Opportunities | About Us | Site Map | Contact RealGM