Team Archives
1st Aug, 2006
Casey At The Bat

13th Jul, 2006
Honor For Clemente Ignites Old Debate

Full Archive

MLB Columns
Search
RealGM Poll
Which team will sign Matt Holliday?

Yankees
Red Sox
Angels
Mets
Cardinals
Other



Poll Archives
Honor For Clemente Ignites Old Debate
Paul Merchan. 13th July, 2006 - 6:10 pm


Current Features
L.A. DODGERS:
What The Dodgers Need This Winter

L.A. ANGELS:
Grading The Deal: Angels Re-Sign Bobby Abreu

MILWAUKEE:
Grading The Deal: Twins Deal For J.J. Hardy

N.Y. YANKEES:
Yankees' ALCS Hopes Hang On Free Agents

ST LOUIS:
Why The Cardinals Will Beat The Dodgers

PHILADELPHIA:
Phillies Begin Title Defense

WASHINGTON:
Finally Good Business Sense

ATLANTA:
Big Series Looming With Phillies

BOSTON:
Is Smoltz Done Or Just Warming Up?

TAMPA BAY:
Rays Haven't Reclaimed Last Year's Magic

SEATTLE:
Griffey's Wonderful Season Goes Beyond The Numbers

CHICAGO CUBS:
Making Moves Before The All-Star Game

CHICAGO WHITE SOX:
'Striking Out' With The White Sox, Late May

TORONTO:
Are The Jays For Real?

SAN FRANCISCO:
Behind Lincecum's Struggles On Opening Day

N.Y. METS:
Grading The Deal: Mets Cheaply Sign Sheffield

FLORIDA:
2009 Marlins Spring Summit

HOUSTON:
2009 Season Preview: Houston Astros

BALTIMORE:
2009 Season Preview: Baltimore Orioles

TEXAS:
2009 Season Preview: Texas Rangers

CLEVELAND:
Let 24 Bat Third?

OAKLAND:
Grading The Deal: Oakland Signs Cabrera

ARIZONA:
‘Striking Out’ With The D-Backs: Late-February

SAN DIEGO:
‘Striking Out’ With The Padres: Mid-February

COLORADO:
'Striking Out' With The Rockies, Mid-February

KANSAS CITY:
Grading The Deal: Royals Make Huge Investment In Greinke

DETROIT:
Auditing The Detroit Tigers 2008 Season

CINCINNATI:
Auditing The Cincinnati Reds 2008 Season

MINNESOTA:
Auditing The Minnesota Twins 2008 Season


RealGM Search
Search:

It was a historic moment after the fifth inning at PNC Park in Pittsburgh during the MLB All-Star Game on Tuesday. The presentation of the commissioner’s achievement award to one of that town’s most beloved stars brought tears to the eyes of many, including tough guys like Ozzie Guillen. Roberto Clemente’s wife, Vera, was on hand to receive the award for her late husband, still a legend in the Pirates organization and around baseball.

However, the presentation of the award not only brought joy to the occasion, but also sparked a debate that has been going on for quite some time- that Clemente’s No. 21 should be retired from baseball.

Latinos all over the country, especially in baseball circles, have been vying for such a distinction for the Puerto Rican Clemente, who they say opened doors for many Latinos to play baseball, breaking language and cultural barriers in the process. Today, a large percentage of major leaguers are of Latin descent.

Many others argue that such a recognition is excessive, citing that only one number has been retired from baseball altogether- No. 42, that of Jackie Robinson, the first African-American ever to play in the Major Leagues. Especially in the black community, the argument stands that Jackie Robinson had to endure more racial hardships in baseball than Clemente, and that therefore, his number 42 should remain the only one retired from all of baseball.

Spanish-speaking radio stations mentioned the debate the morning after the All-Star game, pushing for No. 21 to be retired. Its still to be seen if MLB Commissioner Bud Selig will even consider such a motion, being that it could possibly cause cultural or racial tensions, since the retiring of No. 42 was so emotional for the game.

Clemente’s Hall of Fame credentials are impressive in their own right. He was a World Champion in 1960 and 1971 with the Pirates and finished his career with an even 3,000 hits, his last hit coming on the last day of the 1972 season. He died on a plane crash in that same year, while helping deliver supplies to an earthquake-ravaged Nicaragua. Those who want his number retired explain that the circumstances of his death further qualify him for such an honor.

Whether he will join Jackie Robinson in those ranks is yet to be seen. What’s certain is that his impact on baseball is still felt, as was witnessed on the field during this year’s All-Star game, and on the field during baseball games all season, where Latin players are in strong representation.
© 2000-2009 RealGM, L.L.C. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Opportunities | About Us | Site Map | Contact RealGM