Extra Bases Archives
8th Feb, 2012
Grading The Deal: Nationals Go Short-Term With Edwin Jackson

25th Jan, 2012
Grading The Deal: Tigers Take Huge Risk On Prince Fielder

Full Archive

MLB Columns
Search
RealGM Poll
How long of a deal would you give Cole Hamels?

3 years
4 years
5 years
6 years
7 years



Poll Archives
Be The GM: Grady Sizemore Vs. Carlos Quentin
Authored by Christopher Reina - 3rd March, 2009 - 2:25 pm
Current Featured Columns
The Hanging Curve: Burnett, Seattle OBP, Baltimore Pitching & More
A lot has happened in Major League Baseball since the last Hanging Curve, including an injury to a future Hall of Famer (Mariano Rivera), the benching of another (Albert Pujols) and a career-week for a slugger (Josh Hamilton) on a path that could lead to Cooperstown.

Prospect Review (May 6): Teheran, Profar, Cole And More
Checking in on the development of Jurickson Profar, Gerritt Cole, Julio Teheran, Anthony Gose, Jed Bradley.

Where Prince Will Hang His Crown In 2012
If the Jays front office thinks they can form a starting rotation worthy of contending in the East in the next couple seasons, there is no reason to believe that they will not make a run at Prince Fielder.

MLB All-Stars Talk About 'The Decison' From LeBron James
Ryan Braun and Troy Tulowitzki talked to RealGM about LeBron James and starting their own big three.


RealGM Search
Search:

Over the next few weeks as the NCAA Tournament and Spring Training dominate the month of March, we have combined the two for our own March Madness, which will determine who the readers of RealGM will select in the second edition of our 'Be The GM' series.

Though there are many different potential answers, the question is simple; If you were to start a MLB franchise from scratch and had the option to pick any player in the world, who would you pick?

Click here for more information on this series and to read other match-ups.

The AL Central Division title was one by these two teams in three of the four seasons and while one of the below players is a five-tool perennial MVP candidate, the other is an old-fashioned slugger.

Grady Sizemore, CF, Cleveland Indians

Other players considered from the Indians: Cliff Lee, Fausto Carmona

Why he's a franchise player: Grady Sizemore is the kind of player kids dream about becoming when they are 10-years-old. He is a complete ballplayer at the plate and on the field.

Sizemore is 32nd in OPS+ since 2005, which is impressive when considering that only Ichrio and Jose Reyes have more plate appearances during the timeframe.

Sizemore has worked to reduce his strikeouts while increasing his homers and stolen bases. He finished with 33 homers and 38 stolen bases, so he should continue to flirt with 40-40 for the remainder of his 20's.

His best season was possibly 2006 when he had career bests in batting (.290) and slugging (.533), hitting 53 doubles, 11 triples and 28 homers.

Sizemore is a human highlight reel in the centerfield, where he has remarkable range and uses some of that running back mentality from when he was a high school football star in Everett, Washington to chase down balls and crash into walls.

Carlos Quentin, LF, Chicago White Sox

Other players considered from the White Sox: Alexei Ramirez, John Danks, Gavin Floyd, Bobby Jenks

Why he's a franchise player: In an era when the slugger is dying a quick PED-less death, Q-uperman burst onto the stage with the White Sox by hitting 36 homers in 480 at bats. He is a thinking man's slugger, with really remarkable strength, so it would not be surprising to see him average 40+ homers per season over the next eight or nine years with maybe one or two 50+ campaigns.

Ken Williams traded for his fellow Stanford man following the 2007 season and the former 29th overall pick finished 5th in MVP voting and would have had better than a 50/50 shot at winning it if not for his late season injury. Quentin was 8th in OPS+ in 2008 and hit .288/.394/.571.

Though I don't believe 2008 was a fluke season for Quentin, he clearly has three things working against him; a small sample size of success, a mediocre resume defensively and a history for injury (including self-inflicted wounds).

Click here to cast your vote for Sizemore or Quentin.
All content © 2000-2010 RealGM, L.L.C. All rights reserved..
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Opportunities | About Us | Site Map | Contact RealGM