Extra Bases Archives
25th Oct, 2008
Keeping Manny Motivated

10th Oct, 2008
MLB’s 2009 Free Agents

Full Archive

MLB Columns
Search
RealGM Poll
Where will Manny Ramirez sign?

Dodgers
Giants
Yankees
Mets
Nationals
Other



Poll Archives
Grading The Deal: Mets Cut Ties With Lasto
Authored by Brandon Contes - 2nd December, 2007 - 12:46 pm
Current Featured Columns
How Did Last Offseason's Trades Pan Out?
Last year's offseason paid big dividends for the Rays, Phillies, and White Sox, as they acquired important pieces that helped them into October.

The 2008 Reina Value And FIC
For the 3rd time in four years, Pujols was the best in the MLB while Lincecum had the best Reina Value. How did all 1,296 major leaguers perform in relation to their contract?

Grading The Deal: Burnett Gets Payday In Bronx
Roughly two days after CC Sabathia agreed to terms on a monstrous contract, A.J. Burnett swooped in and received a huge payday from the recession-proof Yankees.

Previewing The ALDS
The Angels and Red Sox will score a lot of runs, while the absence of a dominant starter for the White Sox could be the difference.


RealGM Search
Search:

Wasn’t it just a couple of years ago that Lastings Milledge was one of the top prospects in baseball?

Didn’t the Mets have serious discussions about trading Milledge to Boston for Manny Ramirez?

How did this first round draft pick, a five-tool player with so much potential, turn into a 31-year-old catcher who batted .235 last year and a 29-year-old outfielder who had his best season in the pros by batting .272 with 15 homers and 70 RBIs?

If all the Mets could have received in return for Milledge was catcher Brian Schneider and outfielder Ryan Church, then the Mets simply should have said thanks, but no thanks.

After making the mistake of not re-signing Paul Lo Duca, the Mets wisely avoided signing Yorvit Torrealba and made a very nice trade of Guillermo Mota for Johnny Estrada.

Apparently, the Mets never had any intention of keeping Estrada on their roster for too long and now plan to enter the season with Brian Schneider as their starting catcher.

Schneider is a nice defensive catcher, but he provides little to no offense. The Mets would have been better off using Estrada as their everyday catcher.

At age 29, we pretty much know what Ryan Church is. He is a very good fourth outfielder. He is not getting any better; he can provide numbers similar to those that he provided this year.

However, it’s safe to say that if given the full year to play, Milledge could have easily put up comparable numbers to those of Church. Right now, Church is a better defensive player than Milledge, but let’s not forget that Milledge is a centerfielder who was just learning to play the corner outfield positions.

Milledge’s biggest issue on defense was taking poor angles to get to the ball, and that is simply because he has not had the chance to adjust to the corner outfield positions yet. The bottom line is that Milledge is seven years younger and has much more potential than Church.

Milledge plays with an abundance of excitement and energy; he can be cocky at times, but he will do very well for the Nationals and flourish under Manager Manny Acta. Over the next couple of seasons Milledge can become the face of the Washington franchise.

The Mets said that no team really wanted Milledge, and this was the best deal that they could get for him. That still does not make it a good trade. Lastings Milledge has the tools to become an excellent player, much better than Ryan Church and Brian Schneider. The Mets could have made this trade a month from now. There was no reason to rush into trading Milledge especially considering whom they got in return.

Grade for Mets: D

Grade for Nationals B+
© 2000-2008 RealGM, L.L.C. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Opportunities | About Us | Site Map | Contact RealGM